This One Summer
Graphic Novel
Young Adult
This One Summer is a
graphic novel for young adults. Prior to
searching for a young adult graphic novel, I had never heard of this book. As I searched to find where this book was
available, I can across articles that suggested there was some controversy
surrounding this book, and this instantly piqued my interest. In 2016, this book was removed from libraries
in Henning, Minnesota and Longwood, Florida after parents complained about the
books’ use of profanity and mature themes.
The author, Mariko Tamaki said the book is most appropriate for readers
12-18, but that it is an important book for young adults to read. It was
featured in 2018 on a list of “Top ten most challenged books” as the 7th
most challenged book in 2018 and number 1 challenged in 2106. It was challenged for “profanity, sexual
references and certain illustrations”.
In 2014, This
One Summer won the Ignatz award for outstanding graphic novel and the
Eisner Award in 2105 for Best New Graphic Novel. It also received a Caldecott Honor in 2015
and a Printz Honor as well.
This coming-of-age story follows two young girls, Windy and
Rose. They are both on summer vacation
in a beach town named Awago. Rose is the
narrator of the book. She reflects on
the previous summer in Awago and her experiences and insights as she has now
matured another year. Rose cannot remember a summer where she didn’t spend her
time at Lake Awago with her summer friend Windy. Rose and Windy love to explore the beach and
watch rented movies….remember when renting movies
from an actual store was a thing? The
girls reminisce about their past summers and how they are eagerly awaiting for
their bodies to mature and grow boobs. Rose
meets an older teenager named Duncan and soon develops a crush. At Duncan’s they meet other older local
kids. They once hoped that they would
grow up to be like them, but quickly begin to question this when they learn new
derogatory words used by these older kids, like “slut” and “blowjob”.
The story shifts
towards to some turmoil at home, where Rose’s mother and father have intensified
conflicts. Her mother is depressed, and
Rose’s father leaves the house for several days after an argument between her
parents. Rose is very angry with her mom
and calls her mom selfish. Later in the summer, Rose’s father returns back to
the summer cottage, but the tension in the air can be cut with a knife and
neither parent act like the other is there.
Windy and Rose
also discover that Duncan’s girlfriend, Jenny is pregnant. Duncan denies this claim and also suggests
that the baby is not his and has another father. He refuses to make doctor’s appointments
too. Duncan still refuses to accept
responsibility for the child and tells Jenny to never speak to him again. Jenny is distraught and runs off. Rose goes to look for Jenny and discovers
that she is drowning in the ocean. Rose
yells for her mom to save her; she saves Jenny.
This is where Rose’s mom’s source of pain is revealed. Last summer, Rose’s mom had a miscarriage
while swimming in the ocean. Rose feels
horrible for how she treated her mom and forgives her. The novel ends with Rose and Windy
reminiscing and wondering what the next year will hold for them at the lake.
Because of the
mature themes and language, this book is suggested for ages 12-18. After reading the novel, I can understand why
many parents wanted it banned from libraries.
Personally, I feel there is worse language on content more readily
available to preteens and teens daily on tv, YouTube and social media. The story provided in this novel is something
that is very prevalent in today’s world and is very important for youth to read. I would find this graphic novel most
appropriate for high school students.
For classroom activities, I would suggest doing a character
analysis. Duncan, Jenny, Rose, Windy,
Rose’s mom and Rose’s dad would all be great choices for the character
analysis. Another activity could be for
the students to predict what might happen or change when Rose and Windy return
to Lake Awago next summer. What might be
the same and how will things be different.